Sunday, February 27, 2011

The Academics (and some rants on Americans)

I feel I must apologise for my lack of updates. But then again, I did warn you all.

In my defence, I feel not much new has come up; classes have started, so much of my time is taken up with attending courses, doing readings and homework, and waiting around campus. So you see, it isn't all hikes and games down here; I am actually doing some work. In particular, this semester at UCT, I am taking courses Medical Anthropology, Hunters and Herders of South Africa, Afrikaans, and Greek (Ancient, as usual).

Medical Anthropology so far seems like a promising course; the readings can be a bit dense, and as a non-medical anthropologist, I must admit I have some difficulty grasping a few of the more radical concepts. The professor is wonderful though; she does a great job explaining concepts, answering questions, and trying to get to know the students in her rather large lecture. On top of the lectures, I'm also in a tutorial (= discussion session), in which the tutor (= TA) seems an equally competent teacher and medical anthropologist in her own right. The only two downsides I have encountered so far are: that kid (the one that is constantly challenging the professor and the other students, not so much to be constructive or provoke discussion, but simply to look smarter by asking irrelevant questions), and the Americans. I don't want waste too much time bashing my fellow countrywo/men here, since that might take a whole new entry, but I must say I do find it ...disappointing and somewhat insulting even to find large numbers of Americans in the course who for the most part aren't even in the fields of medicine or anthropology, and need to take class time to ask questions about anthropological concepts that they could even have looked up on Wikipedia and saved everybody's time (especially since one of the course pre-reqs was understanding of basic anthropological underpinnings such as cultural relativism). I do appreciate that they are taking this course, presumably to learn something about issues surrounding health and health care in South Africa and the rest of the world, since I really do think that one should try to understand other disciplines -- especially anthropology, as I feel it can have a profound influence on the way one views their surroundings. However, I can't really get over the fact that they all tend to come in late, sit at the back, check their cell phones and make idle chit-chat, and then ask stupid questions.

Since I seem to have started bashing anyway, let me continue. My other major academic course is Hunters and Herders of South Africa, based in the Archaeology Department, and which looks to be a sort of history of Koisan groups, with a particular emphasis on the archaeological and anthropological information we can gleam from living hunter-gatherer or forager groups to try to build a better understanding of our human ancestors, who after all evolved and lived for a significant time in South Africa, among other places. At the moment, our lectures are being given by a PhD student who specialises in rock art; hence, we're learning about rock art at the moment. While I enjoy that the Americans are much less pronounced in this course (and there are a lot more local students who are specialising in Archaeology), I was disappointed several times last week when Americans in my lecture would complain to me or to a friend (who passed on the word to me when they found I was in the same class) about how boring they found the course so far, and that they regret taking it. Okay, so maybe Bleek's linguistic records of the /Xam people, or Marshall's ethnographies of the Jung/qwasi (my spelling might be off there), or rock art, might not be everyone's cup of tea, but if it isn't, why would you take a course on the Hunters and Herders of South Africa through the Archaeology Department? What were you expecting? And please, don't ever call rock art "boring" to my face. Ever. Rock art is fascinating. Everything about rock art is fascinating: the fact that a variety of societies have (/had) some form of rock art; that they contain cultural symbolism that we don't fully understand; that some have survived in extremely good condition (to the point where you can do carbon-dating on charcoal pigments, for example) for such a long time; they're even pretty to look at, if you don't care about the archaeological significance!

Unfortunately, my Afrikaans class is continuing my dislike of living-language courses. The language itself I find fascinating, and fun to learn -- after all, I love languages in general, and there is something refreshing about not declining or conjugating anything. On the other hand, I dislike being patronised in my language courses. I dislike being patronised in general, and being in introductory languages only compounds it, since they never teach you enough of the language to respond to such treatment. Oh well. Hopefully when we get out of the second week of learning the same verbs and pronouns, we can start being more productive. At least I have a fellow Badger and language-lover in the course who agrees with me that students should be forced to take an introductory linguistics course before enrolling in introductory level languages, so professors don't have to spend ages explaining things like verb position, the genitive case, and prefix rules in basic, basic English (usually along the lines of 'Memorise this, and we'll test you on it for two weeks').

If you successfully made it through my rather disappointing remarks on the courses here at UCT, having saved the best for last, I now present the light at the end of the tunnel. The Greek here is amazing. It is the only course I had originally planned on not taking, and it is proving to be the most overall-enjoyable so far. This of course is due to the simple facts that: 1. Classics faculty are nice, as already shown by the ease with which I got into Greek; 2. Classics students are always friendly, because let's face it, you're all suffering the same; 3. Americans do not come to Cape Town to take 3rd semester Greek (although I imagine those that would (come) would be wonderful people: see #2); 4. If you're in a class of only four students you will learn a lot: you will read a lot (as in starting at about a Stephanus page of Plato per day) of Greek, you will translate a lot of English into Greek, and you will become pretty close with your classmates who will gladly help you out with all sorts of not-Greek-related things.

Please, do not be alarmed now that you might think this semester will be a waste of my time and energy. The courses I'm taking really aren't all that bad. As I said, I enjoy all of the content, and for the most part have successfully distanced myself from the Americans who would normally detract from the experience. (This I have accomplished by: understanding the readings, having a background in archaeology/anthropology, enjoying the course, and sitting up front where you don't have to be distracted by their whispering and can meet South Africans who sit up front to learn things, too.) Furthermore, I feel that in a way this is only helping my study abroad experience; I came to South Africa, ostensibly to study the rich anthropology and archaeology this country has to offer, but also to gain some "cultural experience", ὡς λέγουσι*. Having Americans in my courses does help me notice the differences more, since any sample size is better than a sample size of one not-so-American, as I am. But since I seem to have rambled on as Socrates might, perhaps I shall stop here, and pick up another time with the differences I've encountered (hopefully with an anthropologically sound interpretation), and with the extracurricular activities I've been engaging in with the wonderful South Africans I'm not getting to meet in Medical Anthropology or Hunters and Herders of South Africa.

*"As they say".

No comments:

Post a Comment