At this point, I must confess to being a bad anthropologist. Of course, I came to South Africa hoping to becoming a better anthropologist by taking courses such as Hunters and Herders of South Africa or Medical Anthropology, and while I still hope these courses will teach me to be a better anthropologist, I suppose I should start with a good framework on which to build. So for now -- until now -- I realise I have been a bad anthropologist, and now I hope I can reverse that.
One of the things they try to force into you from Day One of anthropology is not to make sweeping generalisations, especially when it comes to social/ cultural features. Of course, on some level we are always making sweeping generalizations, and not just anthropologists; after all, it can be much easier to put things in proper 'categories'. Not to mention we have our own pre-conceptions of how things will be (but at least in archaeology/ anthropology one usually develops a theory based on data already available. -- Look now; I'm making sweeping generalisations!) But in all honestly, I can find it hard to avoid at times, both in and out of class: "Frisbee people are friendlier than the rest", "Americans are obnoxious", "University students drive old, beat-up cars", "Anthropology majors are the best"*.
But more and more now I find myself wary of such over-simplifications, and mostly for the reason that when you are on the receiving end, they sound so incredibly uninformed. I didn't imagine that in Cape Town of all places, I would find myself constantly telling European exchange students that not all Americans are gun-toting, Bush-voting, monolingual bigots. Or clarifying to South Africans that "The Hangover" doesn't really reflect what happens on a daily basis where I come from. And actually I do know most of the rules of rugby, and no I don't follow wrestling. (And I don't want to give you the wrong generalisation that every non-American has these skewed views: one of the Namibian students from my Afrikaans class told me he wanted to visit Minnesota -- Vikings fan, as it turned out.)
This realisation has been slowing coming on, but probably the defining moment for me came when we (the frisbee team) were waiting around for everyone to show up to arrange lifts to our game on Monday night. Of course, this was at the same time as the Ikey Tigers (UCT) were playing their big rivals, the Maties (from Stellenbosch), so of course several of our drivers were running behind from the traffic, complaining about the Maties fans who didn't know their way around and had come early to get spaces for the game. To which somebody jokingly responded, "And of course they're from Stellenbosch, so they all hate you if you're not white." And suddenly I realised just how ...wrong... it sounded; of course, school rivalries always seem to carry some of that edginess (there I go again), but from an outsider's perspective (and possibly from a Stellenboschian perspective as well), it's a really odd statement to hear.
So here's the disclaimer: Whatever I write, no matter how I document my experiences here in Cape Town, South Africa, do not take them as absolute. These are simply case studies -- individual events that have been removed from their context. I don't image my six months at all could cover the range of possibilities that this beautiful school/ city/ country/ continent has to offer. And if I should make generalisations (as I'm sure I will), just take them with a grain of salt -- after all, I'm a rather expressive person, and I like using hyperbole --, and feel free to call me out if you feel I'm being too personally overbearing in my narrative.
Scotty out.
*Okay, that one is a fact.
No comments:
Post a Comment